Rosemary Butter Sandwich Cookies with Orange Blossom Water Buttercream Filling

Ann Marie Craig • December 12, 2019

Rosemary is the perfect foil for the sweet buttercream. Mmmmm. Wouldn't you love these on your Holiday cookie plate?

Christmas is coming, and at Century Farmhouse that used to mean baking a lot of cookies: gingerbread, sugar cookies, pinwheels, shortbreads, snow-on-the-mountains, and pfeffernuss, but we just don't eat the cookies as much now and prefer a few really wonderful desserts to tins and tins of cookies. I have been playing around with some cookie recipes though, adding herbs other than lavender to my butter cookie recipes for example, and I have been getting some striking results. Here is the result of playing with rosemary and citrus - two of my favorite flavors!

Rosemary Butter Sandwich Cookies

These sweet and buttery sandwich cookies are the perfect foil for savory herbs such as rosemary. Paired with the orange blossom water buttercream (recipe below), they are decadent treats!


Ingredients:

2/3 cup butter, softened

2 cups all-purpose flour

3/4 cup sugar

1 egg

1 Tablespoon milk

2 teaspoons dried rosemary, finely chopped or broken

1 teaspoon baking powder

1 teaspoon vanilla

dash salt

Let's make 'em! Preheat oven to 375 degrees F.

1. Beat butter in a large mixing bowl until softened. Add about half the flour and mix well. Add sugar & rosemary, egg, milk, baking powder, vanilla, & salt. Beat until combined well. Beat or stir in remaining flour.

2. Divide dough in half, cover, and chill about 3 hours or until easy to handle.

3. Roll each half of the dough on a lightly floured surface to 1/8-inch thickness. Using a knife or cookie cutters or a glass dipped in flour, cut dough into desired shapes. Place 1 inch apart on an ungreased cookie sheet.

4. Bake in a 375 degree oven for 7 minutes or until done - do not brown the cookies. Cool on the cookie sheet for one minute. Remove cookies from the sheet; cool on a wire rack.

5. Thickly spread the back of one cookie with the Orange Blossom Buttercream (recipe below) and top with the backside of a second cookie to make a sandwich.

Makes about 2 dozen - 2-inch round sandwich cookies

Orange Blossom Buttercream

This luscious frosting is made richer with the addition of a little melted white chocolate. Use this buttercream to frost your favorite cupcakes or cakes too.

Ingredients:

2 ½ cups powdered sugar

2 - 3 Tablespoons milk or cream or half & half

3 Tablespoons butter, softened

3 squares white chocolate, melted (use real white chocolate, not a palm oil substitute)

1 teaspoon grated orange rind - organic orange is best, wash any orange thoroughly before grating

dash of salt

¼ teaspoon (plus a tiny drop or more to taste) Orange Blossom Water

*** A note about the orange blossom water: It is quite concentrated, so don't be tempted to put a lot of it into the frosting or you'll be eating a mouthful of flowers. You can temper some of the sweet floral flavor by grating about 1 teaspoon fresh orange rind into the frosting.

Let's make it!

1. Melt the white chocolate in a microwave-safe bowl for about 1 minute or until it stirs smoothly. Do not over heat.

2. Put all the ingredients except the softened butter and the melted white chocolate into a medium sized mixing bowl. Stir until the sugar and the liquids create a very thick, stiff ball. You might find adding a bit more milk to a very dry mixture helpful, but add it carefully as the frosting thins quickly.

3. Add the butter and the melted white chocolate to the stiff sugar mixture and stir or mix to create a smooth buttercream frosting.

4. Frost the cookies and eat one! They are delicious.


Century Farmhouse of West Bend, WI
By Ann Marie Craig December 29, 2024
These chocolatey rolls are a such a decadent treat that it's hard to eat just one.
By Ann Marie Craig December 20, 2024
Infuse your home with the cozy scents of winter.
Century Farmhouse Fall soap release dates
By Ann Marie Craig October 7, 2024
New soaps and scents for our fall 2024 Century Farmhouse soaps are being released soon. Read on for the release date of your favorite soap!
By Ann Marie Craig February 6, 2022
Bake an old fashioned spice cake from a vintage recipe, then frost it with Buttermilk Buttercream laced with whiskey vanilla. Top the cake with pretty slices of dried pink apples. A treat for your Valentine.
By Ann Marie Craig January 3, 2022
January 6 is the Twelfth Day of Christmas and in the German tradition is celebrated with a special cake called Koenigskuchen. Here's the recipe for the rich, buttery, fruity version made in the north of Germany even today.
By Ann Marie Craig July 23, 2021
Making fresh, old-fashioned lemonade is easy (recipe included), but add blueberries and lavender, or lavender and mint, or raspberries and mint, and you have a party! The lemonades will dance with flavor.
By Ann Marie Craig March 11, 2021
We have been making soaps with maple sap for more than a decade, and since the sap is running again right now, it seems like a good time to create another soap! Read about the soaps we've known and loved in the past and give us your two cents' worth of ideas for a new soap this year.
Join us on March 20 and learn to make Peat Pot Gift Cups, perfect for your table or to give!
By Ann Marie Craig March 5, 2021
Using simple materials such as peat pots and a little paint, you can craft pretty little cups to hold everything from potted flowers to children's Easter treats. Join us on Saturday, March 20 for a virtual crafting get-together. It'll be fun!
By Ann Marie Craig February 19, 2021
By Ann Marie Craig January 22, 2021
The chilly days of January are perfect for savoring a cup of rich, hot cocoa. Curl up with a cup made from Ann Marie's new recipe - downloadable from a link in the blog post.
More Posts